F1 testing: Mercedes beneath stress from easy-to-drive Ferrari – BBC Sport

F1 testing: Mercedes beneath stress from easy-to-drive Ferrari – BBC Sport
Leclerc, 21, set the quickest on day two of testing in Barcelona

The message popping out of the primary Components 1 pre-season check was as clear because it will get right now of yr – Ferrari are a step forward of the sector, and world champions Mercedes have some catching as much as do.

The Ferrari was fast each time it went out, acquired all the way down to quick instances with obvious ease, regarded comfy to drive and responsive out on the observe, and was dependable. Though issues at Mercedes improved significantly on the ultimate day, their instances weren’t coming as simply or incessantly.

That was the sensation even earlier than Mercedes’ drivers started to speak to the media, and once they did, they backed it up.

  • F1 testing 2019: Which is the best-looking automotive?
  • F1 Gossip
  • Components 1 in 2019: The tales that would outline the brand new season

“Ferrari are very, very sturdy proper now, as you’ve got seen,” Lewis Hamilton stated. “They’re racking up nice mileage as effectively. It seems that they’ve a greater package deal than that they had final yr, which implies it will be much more of a problem for us.”

“Irrespective of which type of gas load or engine modes they’re working,” his team-mate Valtteri Bottas stated, “no matter you attempt to right for, in any case they’re fast. Each brief runs and lengthy runs. So I believe we really feel at this level they’ll be a bit forward.

“By way of automotive behaviour, we nonetheless have work to do getting the stability collectively. With the brand new guidelines, it’ll be a giant improvement race. We do not assume anybody goes with any such automotive on this check to the primary race, together with us.

“We do have new elements coming for the primary race. [But] we will not actually depend on that being an improve. We do want, even with this spec of automotive, to attempt to make it higher and faster.

  • Ferrari higher than final yr – Hamilton
  • Ferrari are ‘a bit forward’ says Bottas

Within the context of Mercedes’ 5 consecutive drivers’ and constructors’ championship doubles, these claims are going to be taken by many with a minimum of a pinch of salt.

Talking on the ultimate day of the check, Ferrari’s Charles Leclerc was eager to downplay the importance of the outcomes to this point.

“The efficiency has no sense for now as a result of it stays testing,” stated the crew’s new recruit, who was instantly at dwelling and really fast within the pink automotive. “They’re in all probability not pushing and we aren’t both. We do not know the way a lot the others are sandbagging so we’ll see on the first race.”

That interprets as: I will imagine Mercedes are lagging behind after I see it – for now, let’s assume they aren’t exhibiting their true tempo. Or ‘sandbagging’, as F1 lexicon has it.

Reducing by the fog of numbers

Bottas, 29, says Ferrari are ‘a bit forward’ of his Mercedes crew

Even with their enchancment on the ultimate day, the proof suggests Mercedes wouldn’t be the crew to beat if the primary race of the season was tomorrow.

It’s all the time troublesome to precisely assess the place groups stand after simply 4 days of winter working – there are too many variables.

Nonetheless, as the primary check on the Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya progressed, an impression shaped. What follows relies on assessing timing knowledge, and data from senior figures throughout the game.

It is essential to say at this level that even the groups, who’ve vastly extra knowledge and skill to analyse it than outsiders, do not know for certain. As one senior determine put it: “You are attempting to glean an excessive amount of info from too little knowledge. And it is the identical for us.”

However that doesn’t imply it’s a must to throw your arms within the air, hand over and simply wait to see how the playing cards fall in qualifying in Melbourne subsequent month. In any case, the place’s the enjoyable in that?

There are issues that may be executed to clear away a number of the confusion, and discern some shapes within the fog.

The checklist of headline quickest lap instances set by every crew is nearly as good as meaningless. It’s topped by Renault, adopted by Toro Rosso and Alfa Romeo (the previous Sauber crew). Mercedes and Ferrari are fourth and fifth, and Crimson Bull solely eighth.

Renault drivers Ricciardo and Hulkenberg recorded the quickest laps in testing

The issue with the headline instances is that the drivers are utilizing totally different tyres, and the checklist takes no account of the quantity of gas on board.

Nonetheless, it’s potential to make a finest effort to right for these two issues.

Groups by no means reveal their gas masses however one can assess components such because the size of the run on which instances have been set, and due to this fact work out the minimal quantity of gas every driver should have had on board and proper for it. It is not an absolute gauge, nevertheless it will get nearer to actuality.

You can too add within the efficiency distinction of the tyre used, and calculate the time again to a baseline for a single compound.

This isn’t a precise science both – not everybody agrees on what the off-sets are between every of the tyres. In Spain this week, Pirelli’s personal estimate for the hole between two of the 5 varieties of tyre was 3 times bigger than that of one of many groups.

However one can take Pirelli’s personal estimates, add just a few opinions from various groups, have a look at the proof of every drivers’ instances, create a ballpark determine, and apply it throughout the board.

From there, one can calculate a determine for the perfect gas and tyre-corrected time by every crew. Many variables stay – together with how onerous the crew have been utilizing the engine – however this technique often will get a consequence that isn’t too far-off from actuality.

That checklist appears like this:


A niche of maybe 0.3secs to Mercedes and Crimson Bull, with differing views on who may be forward, though evidently Mercedes might be a smidge in entrance.

it is about 0.7secs again to Renault who’re maybe 0.2secs or so forward of Alfa Romeo and Haas, the 2 Ferrari buyer groups, with Toro Rosso, McLaren and Racing Level very shut behind them, and really troublesome to decide on between.

There may be then a sizeable hole to Williams, however how a lot is not possible to know, owing to their lack of working following the late arrival of their automotive.

Do not consider the checklist as fully correct. See it as a information, one thing to level in vaguely the suitable route.

The one proviso to it’s that British rookie Lando Norris did one lap on the second-hardest tyre compound on the second day of the check that might have moved McLaren as much as simply behind Renault however then neither he nor team-mate Carlos Sainz acquired close to it once more, and the crew are enjoying down expectations. It is maybe finest for now to deal with it as an anomaly.

Why may Mercedes be struggling?

Mercedes driver Hamilton says that Ferrari are ‘very sturdy’ on the testing

If the Ferrari is a step forward of everybody else – as senior insiders agree it’s – it isn’t essentially a shock.

Whereas Hamilton received the title final yr, Vettel might – and arguably ought to – have executed had he and Ferrari not made so many errors. Between them, they tossed away a minimum of as many factors because the distinction between the 2 males within the championship on the finish of the season.

In each seasons since rule modifications forward of 2017 launched wider, sooner vehicles, Ferrari have began the yr with a greater automotive than Mercedes, solely to implode later within the season.

This yr, there have been additional regulation modifications, most significantly a revision to the entrance wing, making it wider and easier. The intention was to cut back aerodynamic turbulence for the automotive behind and make overtaking simpler.

The wing has modified the best way the vehicles’ aerodynamics work. When guidelines change, some groups get it extra proper than others and the Ferrari has a noticeably totally different entrance wing design from Mercedes.

The Ferrari’s is kind of radical. The varied fins above the primary – or backside – aircraft all begin excessive within the centre of the automotive and slope down in direction of the surface. Mercedes, in the meantime, have a extra conventional-looking wing for now – as do Crimson Bull.

This will or will not be a part of the explanation why the 2 vehicles look like performing in another way – the 2 groups have pursued opposing aerodynamic philosophies in different methods over the past two years but the general efficiency of their vehicles has been very related.

However, for now, regardless of the cause, the Ferrari appears sooner, capable of entry that velocity extra simply, and extra comfy with it. Whereas Bottas was speaking concerning the dealing with stability of the Mercedes nonetheless needing work, sources say that, inside Ferrari, Vettel and Leclerc have been saying they discover the automotive simple to drive, and the restrict comfy to entry.

All of this quantities to a guesstimated snapshot, with little info, on the very earliest level of the season.

And given the standard of Mercedes as a crew, and the best way they and Hamilton have dug deep to win each of the final two titles, few would think about them as something apart from critical title contenders.

As Hamilton put it: “We’re the one crew to have received a championship in a crossover of guidelines scenario and even when we do not begin on the suitable foot on the first race I really feel assured.”

Be that as it could, the early indicators are that the world champions have some catching as much as do.

What about the remaining?

Renault seem to have made a step in direction of the large groups, albeit remaining a long way away, and moved slightly away from the remaining. Behind them, the midfield appears to have develop into even nearer than it already was.

Renault and Alfa Romeo impressed within the first check – Renault for some very sturdy lengthy runs, which put them not that far off the tempo of Mercedes; and Alfa Romeo, the previous Sauber crew now very carefully affiliated to Ferrari, for constant tempo.

However Haas additionally confirmed velocity, Racing Level made it plain they’ve plenty of developments to return to what they are saying is a really fundamental launch automotive, McLaren have had their most dependable first check for 5 years and Toro Rosso set some eye-catching instances, rookie Alexander Albon ending up with second quickest lap all week.

As for Williams, it was a troublesome check, the automotive not showing on observe till the third afternoon, and the crew working to know it as a lot as potential with out searching for lap instances for the day and a half they did have.

The phrase is that Williams might be going through a troublesome season however, simply as with the combat on the entrance, the second check subsequent week will present additional info as to the place everybody stands.

  • Recap – Day one
  • Recap – Day two
  • Recap – Day three
  • Recap – Day 4